Personality, episode by episode
Showing 1–5 of 5 sketches.
A Vanity Fair film critic who is a self-described Luddite and big M. Night guy who had hated The Village at the time and now likes it more on rewatch. Finds the film bafflingly hard to follow yet admires its naked ego; likes the scrunt design. A sucker for a director's trauma and for cinematographer lore.
Stances
- Lady in the Water is mind-bogglingly bad but special
- The scrunt design is good
- He had hated The Village at the time
Humor: Mild, self-deprecating, and good at pitching bits he decides not to do.
In their words
- “I also agree that it is so discombobulatingly bad.” (0:21:15)
- “I love the scrunt.” (1:32:58)
- “I'm a Luddite, and so I've never downloaded a movie from iTunes before.” (1:46:29)
Loves Forrest Gump and had snarked at Button as a young Gawker writer; had never seen the film before preparing. Came around on it on rewatch, valuing the sentimental tone and Daisy's regret.
Stances
- Button deserves reevaluation
- Pitt's casting works because of the special effects reveal
- the logic of the aging is not the point
Humor: Wry personal tangents about Gawker days, his family, and Vanity Fair.
In their words
- “I had never seen button.” (0:14:20)
- “I loved, still love Forrest Gump.” (0:21:35)
A Vanity Fair critic watching Spartacus for the first time; never connected with Gladiator or sword-and-sandal epics, fell for Woody Strode, and finds the homoerotic bath scene fascinating. (Attribution inferred.)
Stances
- Gladiator and the sword-and-sandal genre have never fully clicked for him
- Woody Strode is the movie's best presence
- The first-time view made him appreciate Gladiator more
Humor: Self-deprecating, conversational asides.
In their words
- “I've always had a hard time gladiator and I had a bit of a hard time with this movie.” (1:03:52)
- “I've never seen this before.” (1:03:32)
He is a Vanity Fair critic and a good sport: he went to Cannes and the experience without snark. Fond of Trolls dolls lore and of musical Oscar trivia.
Stances
- The experience was sincere and well staffed
- The film is overstuffed
Humor: Running mock-grandiose bit that Trolls are his creation.
In their words
- “Well, the prophecy had told me that I was never to look directly upon my trolls.” (0:05:47)
- “It was probably the last experience I'll ever have in public.” (1:46:49)
Has a personal tie to the film from freshman year at a Catholic school, defended it to friends, and has since conceded they were right. Loves Kurt Russell's gentle turn and the last fifteen minutes with Sigur Ros. Can't stand the first-act chemistry and the dialogue about cats.
Stances
- C plus for the bulk, B for the last 15 minutes
- Reads the film as a man trying to turn his life back into a Crowe movie
- Apologizes to his college friends for defending the movie
Humor: Warm, wry, quick on callbacks to past episodes.
In their words
- “It's a bad movie.” (1:54:53)
- “And the rest of the movie is a guy trying to make his life like a Cameron Crowe movie again.” (1:38:49)
- “And I think those last 15, 20 minutes are really effective.” (1:37:06)