Personality, episode by episode
Showing 1–5 of 5 sketches.
Devoted to the Friday Night Lights show and cares most about its marriage, character work and Texas setting. Loves a high school football film, small-town Texas and Billy Bob; a sucker for Kyle Chandler, Tammy and Eric. Can't stand the film leaving Sharon unused.
Stances
- The TV show can't be matched, but that does not slight the film
- Coach Taylor's speeches beat Coach Gaines's
- The film needed a Gaines marriage sex scene
- The reboot must stay in Texas
- Cruise would make a deranged, mesmerizing Gaines
Humor: Wry self-aware fandom, deadpan sports-fan jabs, mock outrage.
In their words
- “I love a high school football film.” (0:04:56)
- “What it really is is like the best portrayal of a marriage and the history of TV.” (1:01:11)
- “It's only Coach Gaines in the climax and I think that tips it forever to Coach Taylor.” (0:47:49)
Drawn to despairing divorce films like Marriage Story, analytic about tone and character psychology, and a Michael Douglas-comedy booster (Hank Pym). Hates cruelty to animals in movies.
Stances
- Marriage Story is her top divorce ode
- Gavin is secretly engineering the Roses' war
- Cruelty to the pets is painful to watch
- Pushes a Body Heat plus Fatal Attraction plus Roses triple feature
Humor: Mock-solemn legalistic analysis and deadpan Ravens-fan despair.
In their words
- “Marriage story is my number one of the boundback divorce odes” (0:03:21)
- “Mallory immediately went into a dark, just horrible despair.” (1:10:22)
- “I'm going to throw out a conspiracy theory as a hottest take” (0:57:15)
- “I just would like to talk for another moment if we if we can about the animals in the crosshairs” (0:53:21)
Mallory loves the mythic and literary side of stories: the hero's journey, Game of Thrones, Bull Durham's existential edge. She is protective of the movie against Ebert's critique and a sucker for character details and performances (Pop and Red). She dislikes the book-faithful tragedy being called better for 1984.
Stances
- Bull Durham is her favorite sports movie
- Baseball's godlike myth-making is the draw, not a flaw
- The Natural fits Campbell's hero's journey and Arthurian legend
- Brimley's Pop is the heart of the film
- A darker, book-faithful remake makes sense now
Humor: Deadpan reactions and research-backed zingers, plus Game of Thrones asides and teasing Bill about his mispronunciations.
In their words
- “I love contests of skill.” (0:31:14)
- “It's bad critique.” (0:18:46)
- “Wonder Boy is Excalibur.” (0:16:36)
Adores the original Gladiator and a swoony cast (Mescal, Pascal); cares about structure and what a sequel owes its predecessor. Struggles with sloppy backstory, tonal inconsistency and the retcon. A sucker for the fun of a night at the movies.
Stances
- Had a blast but couldn't stop thinking about whether the movie should exist
- The sequel invites a one-to-one comparison with the first and loses
- Macrinus is the most interesting part of the film
- Wants more Pedro Pascal
Humor: Warm, self-deprecating and fan-girly, with specific food and office-life details.
In their words
- “I had fun in the movies.” (0:14:36)
- “I wanted more Pedro.” (0:33:35)
A devoted fan of the 1998 Mulan and Disney musicals, loves a theme and magic in a story, and loves The Last Jedi. Cannot stand a remake that loses the spirit of its source. Sucker for a well-integrated musical number.
Stances
- The songs and tone are the heart of the original
- Magic undercuts Mulan's message
- Remakes should channel what made the original special
- Missed Mushu's mentorship
Humor: Self-aware oversharer who sets out to be brief and then talks about concession snacks.
In their words
- “I would want the remake to understand what made the original one special.” (0:30:43)
- “I love magic in a story. Frankly, there are a few things I love more. than magic in a story.” (0:21:26)